Tuesday, 4 December 2007

The mote in Britain's eye

Most Britons, of all religions and none, seem to think it was ridiculous for the Sudanese authorities to imprison Gillian Gibbons for letting a class of 7-year olds call their teddy bear "Mohammad".  I wonder how many of them support the English Common Law against blasphemy and the proposed UK statutory law against incitement to religious hatred.  Although there are differences of degree and severity between Sudan and the UK, there is no difference in kind or principle.
I hope all who criticize these laws in Sudan will oppose them in the UK.
 

Labels:

Sunday, 20 May 2007

House of Lords reform

After a lifetime of opposing the existence of an undemocratic House of Lords, I now find myself relying on their Lordships to protect my rights under the Freedom of Information Act to enquire into MPs' activities.

Make no mistake. A second, elected chamber, dominated by the parties that dominate the Commons, would be most unlikely to protect us from the elected dictatorship of the Commons. My solution would be a House of randomly selected citizens with a fixed term of office - a sort of national jury similar to the Citizens' Assembly that reviewed the voting system in British Columbia. Although such a house would be broadly politically representative, none of its members would owe his or her position to a political party, so it would be very difficult to operate a whip system. The house would also be broadly representative by other factors, such as age, sex, ethnicity and religion.

Labels:

Saturday, 17 March 2007

Civil liberties

It's rather ironic that we are celebrating the 200th anniversary of the abolition of the slave trade while the UK's most illiberal government since 1945 is busily finding more and more and more ways of eroding our freedom - CCTV, ID cards, road congestion charging, genetic profiling, detention without trial, abolition of juries and, most recently, a proposal to allow the police to fingerprint anyone they suspect of breaking the law.

Of course, the argument is that these measures help to deter crime and catch criminals and that honest citizens have nothing to fear. However, that's only so long as we have a government which, despite being so illiberal by historical UK standards, is still more liberal than many foreign governments. There is a fear that these measures could be used by future governments to control dissent and suppress legitimate opposition. The road congestion proposal, for example, would enable the Government to track motorists. It would give liberal governments more information than they need and give illiberal governments more information than we should trust them with.

Labels: